Introduction
Market driven management is one of the modern
techniques developed to bring significant changes
into a business through addressing the principle
aspects affecting the performance of the business.
Some of these aspects include aggressive competition,
rapid technology changes, and utilization of spare
capacity, increasing requirements and demands
of the clients and rising costs of products and
services. The adoption of market driven management
techniques thus assists in addressing roadblocks
or obstacles that somewhat serve as tools in the
transformation of an organization.
Market Driven Management - The 5 C's
The market driven management as generally agreed
upon by a number of management experts and economics
include what are termed as the 5 C's. These are
'costs, capabilities, customers, competitors,
and cross functional teams'.
Taking each of the 5 C's in brief, one may observe
that costs require to be understood and emphasis
for lowering the same on a constant basis. Capabilities
take into account the ability of the organization,
and whether this ability fulfill the requirements
and needs of the market. The customers must well
be studied and there real needs fully comprehended
to provide for a better product or set of services.
The aspect of competition duly considers and assesses
the performance and strategies of competitors,
in turn allowing the organization to develop plans
and strategies accordingly. The last aspect of
cross-functional teams takes into account the
inclusion of concerned members of the organization,
including the management and the employees in
the entire process of development of products
and services of the respective organization.
Thus, all these 5 C's of market driven management
serve to
a) Define principle issues and areas of priorities
in an organization.
b) Serve to provide impetus for re-focusing the
organization in recognizing the principle issues.
c) Allows the organization to correctly evaluate
and calculate the actual value of economics of
each respective department or business segment
d) Serve to provide end markets for the organization
e) And ensure that strategies and plans once finalized
need due assessment.
Lambin Theory of Market Driven Management
Perhaps one of the most successful and popular
market driven management theories has been one
presented by Jean Jacques Lambin. Theory presented
by Lambin takes on a truly market oriented approach,
as it not only challenges the traditional concepts
of marketing, it adopts and emphasizes on the
'functional' role of marketing. Lambin's theory
thus enlarges the market definition to include
the principle players such as competitors, distributors,
as well as prescribes, as well as the various
customer groups present in the wider macro-marketing
environment. Furthermore, Lambin also takes into
account the marketing strategy and shows how strategic
decisions are implemented at the organization's
operational level. Perhaps best proven from the
case studies on manufacturing, service sector,
consumer and business-to-business sectors, Lambin's
theory of market driven approach provides an excellent
module for organizations both at the national
level, as well as the international level. Lambin's
theory thus serves as an excellent guide to market-oriented
management, international management principles,
day-to-day needs for a guidance to long term strategy
in organizations duly supported by an information
system, and strategies which duly serve the changing
and demanding needs of a competitive global environment.
Case Studies of Different Products
One of the vital areas where impact of market
driven management has been most felt are the brand
strategies of international organizations. Unlike
to earlier practice of developing brands adapted
to the needs of the local markets, the examples
of which can be found in multi-domestic marketing,
market driven management strategies duly favors
the development of global brands which comprise
of the same product, exactly the same name, and
enjoys the same position in all the markets. One
of the best examples of present day organizations
practicing such a strategy is that of Unilever
of England which has concentrated its entire focus
on some 400 brands, all of which have international
presence, or those which have international potential.
This also brings us to discuss one of the strategies
addressed in Lambin's theory, one that emphasizes
on global brad creation.
In pursuing strategies to create global brands,
majority of the organizations have adopted two
types of strategies. The first takes into account
the expansion of the local brand in international
markets. Examples of such strategies can be observed
in products such as 'Evian' a mineral water brand,
which first found fame in France, before expanding
to the international markets. Similar strategy
was observed in the expansion of 'Barilla', a
pasta brand from Italy, which enjoys a leading
name in pasta brands worldwide, before being famous
in Italy. Another product, 'Nivea' produced by
Beirersdorfin of Germany also pursued a similar
strategy and became famous first in Germany, then
across the expanse of Europe, and than worldwide.
The example of Coca-Cola need not be mentioned,
which also pursed exactly similar strategy. Some
of the primary advantages in oursuing such a strategy
includes creation of a winning local brand, and
increasing its chances of success. Pursuit of
such a strategy also allows the organization to
'progressively' build up a brand on a truly international
basis, one that would be a less risky proposition,
and equally less expensive for the respective
organization. The pursuit of such a strategy also
ensures that minimal expenses are incurred, even
if the expansion on a global scale fails for a
given product.
The second such strategy comprises of creating
a brand that is global from the first day of its
production. Such brands are launched on a global
scale at the same time, with Procter and Gamble
as one such organization. Products launched in
such a manner include Pringles, Swiffer and Kangoo,
all of which have indeed become famous through
out the world at the same time. One of the primary
advantages of pursuing such a strategy is to launch
a product in such a rapid speed, same name, and
placing in practically every market, in turn benefiting
from the requisite economies of scale. One of
the only drawbacks is the huge investment that
are a requisite for the same product to be launched
across the globe, yet remaining unsure on the
success or otherwise of the product. However,
a simple comparison between the above first strategy
and the second strategy shows that majority of
the products that became famous did so from the
pursuit of the first strategy, one where brands
are first made famous locally, and then expanded
on a international markets.
Irrespective of the policy pursued, the product's
movement to the international markets indeed has
some benefits. For example, the benefit gained
from the large economies of scale is truly important
for the organization as well as the product's
popularity across the globe. The benefits gained
in turn provide impetus to the different business
systems of the organization. In addition, the
important department of research and development
is concentrated in fewer international locations,
making the manufacturing process rational, and
through pursuit of standardization the organization
not only benefits of large scale economies of
scale, it also provides for a significant reduction
in the costs of the respect products. In turn
this also provides for significance in the improvements
of financial status and performance of the organization.
Perhaps, one of the largest benefits is the creation
of a truly unique image on a global scale. This
image provides the organization with a 'coherence'
status, as well as allows the organization to
develop a single advertising campaign and advantages
of using international media through the same
single advertisement. (Schiling and Lambin, 2004)
Case Study of GE Plastics and Lambin's Theory
of Market Driven Management
One of the best examples of utilizing Lambin's
theory of market driven management has perhaps
been found to be practiced by GE Plastics of the
International General Electric conglomerate. Acknowledging
the value of real time, and perceiving time as
money, and perhaps pressurized to initiate significant
cuts in costs as well as take on a more rapid
pace in response to the 'increasing volatility
in the market place'. GE with a truly wide of
range of products and services spread across the
globe is one of the conglomerates that is continuously
taking on the shape of a truly digital enterprise.
Practically every process from the activities
of the production workers to the details of each
minute financial transaction is made available
to the numerous plant and corporate managers at
GE. Pursuing a real-time revolution, GE has responded
well through building the various processes, which
have speeded up the organization's ability to
the equally rapidly paced and competitive environment.
Using complex sensing equipment’s such as
radio frequency sensors, global positioning satellites
and worker monitoring software, to software which
operate in-house payroll departments to off-shore
factories across the globe, GE has thus truly
transformed and utilized some of the most modern
and state of the art technology, which has reduced
speeds to provide for split-second results. (Bellini
and Fingar, 2003; Ranadive, 1999; Bradley and
Nolan, 1998)
An example to this respect can be found at General
Electric headquarters where a single individual
is responsible for monitoring what GE terms its
mission-critical operations. These include monitoring
of sales, daily order rates, inventory levels,
including keeping a watch on the savings from
automation from the conglomerate's 13 different
businesses spread across the globe, and doing
all this with a gap of every 15 minutes. The so
called 'digital-cockpits' of GE showing graphical
depictions of the details on minute to minute
basis covering various business performances across
the entire landscape of GE are then checked by
electronic robots who send test transactions through
the entire system, taking no more than a few seconds
to accomplish the entire operation. A trigger
to send automated responses through e-mail or
inquiry whenever a yellow then follows this or
red marks the urgent nature of the status. According
to the management at GE, the idea is not to respond
at the end of the month, end of the quarter or
at the end of the week, and instead take action
on a continual basis.
Taking a brief tour of GE workings, and its gradual
move towards digitizing, one may observe that
in the last couple of years, GE has successfully
digitized each single activity and operation by
creating a digital nervous system. This digital
nervous system connects practically everything
including the organization's IT systems, factories,
employees and suppliers spread across the globe,
customers and its vast range of products. The
objective behind the strategy of making everything
digital 'is to monitor everything in real time'.
This has been successfully accomplished through
the use of sensitive sensors to gauge performance
of jet engines and other machinery in aircraft’s
to the tracking devices which monitor customer
payments, and exactly what it would take to get
the same customers make faster payments. (Bellini
and Fingar, 2003; Ranadive, 1999; Bradley and
Nolan, 1998)
E-buy, E-make, and E-sell
The above mentioned strategy of making everything
turn digital has been segregated into three principle
areas, namely E-buy, E-make, and E-sell respectively.
Thus, GE's digitization drive notes that E-make
is all about using the digital cockpit which serves
as the hub for entire interaction within the GE
organization, and strives to make things and activities
operate and run at a faster pace.
The second strategy of E-sell is one where interaction
with the GE global customers is speeded up. An
example to this respect is the GE Polymerland
Web, which has helped customer’s easy access
to for researching GE's resin products and prices.
An accomplishment to this respect is the GE strategy
of cutting some 300,000-phone calls per year to
service its representatives across the globe.
The result of this tremendous cutting is rise
in speeds at which customers gain access to GE,
and the response by GE, as also cutting unit's
costs by 35 percent over a five year period. Using
the technique of E-selling, GE has also gained
its sales as well as cutting back on costs by
up to 60 percent, aside from enhancing the speed
of the entire operations.
The third strategy of E-buy tackles GE's global
suppliers, interacting with them in a better and
faster pace. An example to this respect was observed
in GE's web-based auctions, which fetched more
than 680 million dollars in 2001 alone. In addition,
there was the factor of precious time saved from
these auctions. Prior to the adoption of digital
technology, GE's customers were not quite aware
of the products, or what GE actually expected
from their buyers. With the introduction of new
system, buyers are able to buy off pre-negotiated
contracts, which saves precious time, money as
well as investments and efforts, which would otherwise
be wasted. (Bellini and Fingar, 2003; Ranadive,
1999; Bradley and Nolan, 1998)
Though requiring a smaller investment, yet the
vital area of billing was too enhanced, and significant
improvements made at GE. For example, GE collected
additional data on customers with a practice of
making late payments on their bills. GE initiated
a process through which payment information on
such customers was collected, and duly passed
on the respective salesperson of the respective
area. Thus, the services of the would-be collector
was eliminated and instead the salesperson was
utilized to make the collection, a strategy which
alone saved a significant 6 million dollars in
interest payments for GE's global business.
Stressing on savings on both time and money,
and making an excellent relationship thereof,
GE has thus been able to create a truly 'cocktail
explosive of time based change' intended to eliminate
inefficiencies by utilizing 'the ability the gather,
use and disseminate' information. At the same
time, many experts may view the adoption of and
getting to real-time parameters as requiring huge
investments in terms of both technology as well
as human resources. Yet, the levels accomplished
by GE are not unique, as other organizations are
equally competing to reach such levels. Examples
to this respects may be found in response to call
center inquiries which have witnessed a tremendous
fall, from as long as 8 hours a few years back,
to less than 10 seconds today. The practice of
refreshing a data warehouse took approximately
a month's time, which today has dropped to less
than an hour. The time to make a custom-built
personal computer was something like 6 weeks,
an endeavor accomplished today in less than 24
hours. All these activities are evidence of accomplishments
at increasing value of real time, and earnings
thereof. (For GE, digitization efforts alone saved
the organization approximately 1.6 billion dollars
as of 2001). (Bellini and Fingar, 2003; Ranadive,
1999; Bradley and Nolan, 1998)
Gaining on Strategic Advantage and Changing Conditions
The GE's cockpit model, which uses digital technology
for practically each action and focuses on real-time
movements, is also about strategic advantage.
The strategic advantage concerns the monitoring
of business on a continual basis, and reacting
to the change as and when they occur, instead
of simply shooting in the dark, as is perhaps
the practice of majority of today's organizations.
This is yet again a follow-up of Lambin's theory
of market driven management, which emphasized
on adapting to the changes and reacting thereof.
GE has duly taken on this concept, and integrated
it into its sales strategy for example. Using
the technique of real time, GE has been able to
use new information and merge it with the existing
information and while doing so, offer new products
and services as well. For example in 2000 GE introduced
the concept of online kiosks at some of the company's
existing branches of the 'Home Depot'. The Online
facility thus offers customers the facility to
order an appliance, select a delivery date and
time, as well as instantly inform whether their
particular request will or will not be honored.
(Bellini and Fingar, 2003; Ranadive, 1999; Bradley
and Nolan, 1998)
Perhaps the greatest advantages of adopting real
time accompanied by the cockpit module for GE,
has been the need for weekly operations reports.
Prior to the induction and use of digital cockpit,
some of the operations figures were not available
till the end of the week. With the current system
of digital cockpits, information is uploaded on
a continual basis, and action taken upon immediately.
For example, past-due invoices allows salespersons
to find out the exact amount of leverage available
to them over price, in turn allowing them to act
on such figures accordingly to the benefit of
the organization.
Some Drawbacks of Real Time and Digitization
Concepts
Though GE has made tremendous advancements in
the adoption of real time value based systems,
and digital cockpits to control and monitor with
significant benefits to the organization, there
are some serious flaws as well. For example, the
aspect of huge investments as also reiterated
in the above paragraphs. GE spent approximately
1.5 billion-dollar in employee time, hardware,
software and other expenses to acquire real time
based systems around the globe. Second drawback
is one, which addresses the aspects of trusts
and monitoring. GE's command and control digitized
system serves to disrupt the important element
of local decisions making, as this is being carried
out from the headquarters. It also serves to force
responsibilities at local level, an aspect that
is the domain of the local decision making official/representative.
Critics of GE's modern modules are of the view
that today's organizations are need of US marine
style management or doctrine where micro-management
does not exist, and where local decisions are
the responsibility of the local representative,
and not the center or command. Other equally important
drawbacks include the loss of human labor and
rise in unemployment, as both these aspects owe
their rise to the expansion of digital technology.
According to estimates predicted by Cap Gemini
Earnest & Young, the gradual rise in real-time
initiatives could lead a rise of unemployment
from anywhere 2 to 2.5 percent, simply from the
labor savings in technology. Similarly, GE's own
research vice president has noted during a conference
on real time enterprises, that the organization
was able to make savings to the tune of 3 million
dollars from the cut in payroll costs in 2001
alone, and by the year 2005, GE will have reduced
its total workforce by 10 percent. These are aside
from the eruption of skirmishes on the sensitive
labor-management relations from the close monitoring
practices adopted under the real time initiatives
and maneuvers, and the various challenges faced
by the management while taking along the organization
towards a real-time movement. (Bellini and Fingar,
2003; Ranadive, 1999; Bradley and Nolan, 1998)
The above discussion thus provides for a comprehensive
and detailed set of practices adopted from the
Lambin’s theory of market driven management,
including the extent and height of accomplishments
as well as some drawbacks.
|