It was around
the year 1999 that Internet-based recruitment
services truly took off in China. Job-hunters
quickly turned to the Internet as a possible source
of help and were not dissatisfied. By 2001, there
were more than 200 websites relating to employment
and recruitment opportunities. The popular ones,
such as Beijing-based Zhaopin.com and ChinaHR.com
and Shanghai-based 51job.com, were responsible
for catering to a massive 70% of the expanding
market. The highest total for Zhaopin.com was
an impressive 1 million page views per day and
1000 new job listings every day. Globalization
and common use technology has definitely opened
up the doors for Internet-based recruitment services
in China, as is evident from the above statistics
(People’s Daily, 2001).
Job-seekers in China however, showed mixed responses
to this use of Internet technology as means of
attaining employment. Some were ecstatically positive
about the entire affair such as Zeng Yunqiang,
who works for a foreign-funded company in Pudong.
Yunqiang used the online recruitment services
available on the Internet to secure a job for
himself and rid himself of the hassles of the
traditional methods. According to him, “It
was like jumping into a sea. I could update my
resume online and instantly contact companies
by e-mail.” But other people had less successful
results and consequently, less positive views
about Internet-based recruiting services. Jhin
Zu, a student enrolled at the Fudan University,
failed in his attempts to find a job online. Zu,
who was a journalism major, said that even though
all of his room mates registered online in search
of jobs, the responses from companies were rare.
Even when the companies did give feedback, they
often said that these students lacked the required
experience (People’s Daily, 2001).
However, in spite of the probability of lack of
suitable response, the Internet recruitment services
do remain a feasible method of job-hunting in
China. The country has a shortage of candidates
as its main employment problem and needs as many
recruitment options as are available to secure
the needed staff. Foreign companies which are
operating in China realize this and are hence
very aggressive and creative in their staffing
efforts. Companies with established in operations
also consider the Internet as an effective employment
tool because newspapers, though are inexpensive,
create the problem of delay owing to the 1-2 month
publishing backlog. Also, an absence of qualified
personnel for management, finance, human resource,
marketing and other professional positions remains
a problem for Chinese employers. Hence, they view
the Internet as another tool which they must exhaust
to attain a solution to their problem. As for
job-seekers, there exist both categories: the
ones who believe Internet-based recruitment services
to be the solution their every trouble, and those
who have had less-than-favorable experiences.
But, desperate job-hunters still use the Internet
as an effective job-search tool (Gross, 1997;
Kucznski, 1999).
In the U.S., more and more companies are using
online sources for recruitment and by 2000, 47%
of employers were said to use the Internet for
recruitment. Specifically, research showed that
a large number of companies (42%) recruit their
professional staff this way, while 36% scout for
Managerial level employees and only 23% hunt for
employees to fill manual positions. According
to Imogen Daniels, employee resourcing advisor,
IPD, “The Internet as a recruitment tool
is here to stay. I anticipate more employers switching
to this method of recruitment”. (47% of
employers use the Internet for recruitment)
A survey conducted by Austin Knight Inc., a recruitment
and employee communications firm based in Sausalito,
California, found that around two-thirds of the
companies surveyed believed the Internet to be
a more cost-effective tool for recruitment than
all other available tools. Employers cited the
following advantages: increased likelihood of
finding the perfect choice as there is access
to more people as well as a broader selection
of applicants, a greater control over target employee,
access to people with a technical background and
expertise in computers, as well as ease of use
and economy (Starske, 1996).
These advantages may remain, job recruitment
web sites may be the most cost-effective option
available to employers and their numbers and use
may be growing, but a study released by Forrester
Research Inc. found that these web sites still
do not work as well as they should. Analysts for
the Cambridge Mass. firm that though the process
of job search might be made a whole lot easier,
the sheer magnitude of the task has led to a whole
lot of inefficiency. The quality of job-recruiting
web sites varies from one site to the next and
there is no fixed standard. Aside from this, online
resume tools have time and again proven to be
unproductive and the massive amounts of resumes
distributed over the thousands of recruitment
web sites have created a messy clutter. This mess
is holding back the industry, estimated to grow
to $7.1 billion by 2005, from significantly moving
ahead (Featherly, 2000).
According to Charlene Li, a senior analyst at
Forrester, “It's sort of a mixed bag, but
basically people are not very satisfied. There's
a huge amount of promise, and in some cases they
make the whole job search very much easier. But
because it's easier, it's also a lot more cumbersome.
The promise isn't being fulfilled (Featherly,
2000).”
Even with the inefficiencies involved, there
is talk of increasing online spending on recruiters’
parts. By 2004, this spending was supposed to
increase by 52%. The share of print advertising
and fee-based search agencies in overall spending
budgets was expected to drop. User on the other
hand, do not always have posituive experiences
relating to online job-hunting. Some job-seekers
find job web sites difficult to use and also that
a lot of the job listings are the same across
different web sites. The old problem of not getting
reposnses after submitting resumes surfaces here
as well, which reduces the quality of the experience
for these users (Featherly, 2000).
All the same, the future is still bright for
the concept of Internet-based recruitment services,
and the existent problems of inefficiency and
an over-cluttered environment are all targeted
to be sorted by the use of technology in this
area. According to Li, “what's going to
happen is that these job sites are going to evolve
into ... a place where you manage your career
just like a stock portfolio.” Hence, the
use of online job sites is only going to become
more popular with every passing day (Featherly,
2000).
|