| The significance
of strategic leadership in successfully managing
organizations is considered as the key to success
in business as in political and social organizations.
Strategy, a term widely used today in management
discourses, in its original sense means “leading
an army”; hence it is only natural that
studying strategic leadership essentially involves
studying the leadership qualities of political
and historic leaders who succeeded in mobilizing
mass and successfully leading them towards realizing
their political and social objectives. These lessons,
no doubt would be beneficial to business organizations,
as it proves beneficial in understanding the success
factors of political organizations. The paper
attempts to study and analyze the ideologies and
strategies as well as the leadership styles adopted
by Ho Chi Minh, the founding leader of Vietnamese
communist party, who successfully led the Vietnamese
society to independence from colonial forces.
Ho Chi Minh – The Vietnamese Communist
Leader
Ho Chi Minh, the Vietnamese communist leader who
regained Vietnam from the clutches of the French
and Japanese colonialists is well known for his
leading role in the war between North and South
Vietnam, commonly known as the Vietnam War (1954-1975),
and also as the perpetual spiritual leader of
the modern Vietnamese Communist regime. His active
and prominent role in Vietnamese freedom struggle
is apparent from the time Japan surrendered to
the Allied Forces, leading to the end of World
War II, until the establishment of the united
Democratic Republic of Vietnam, called the Socialist
Republic of Vietnam. An analysis of Ho Chi Minh’s
leadership confirms Peters and Waterman assertion
that leaders are not born, but effective leaders
emerge as organizations form and face new challenges
and problems in the course of achieving their
objectives. [Peters and Waterman, 1982]
The public attention turned to Ho Chi Minh, as
a public leader, when he declared the independence
of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam in Hanoi
on September 2, 1945, following Japan’s
surrender to allied forces in August 1945. [Hammer,
1966] The event is considered next in prominence
to the 1917 October Revolution in Russia as it
marked the beginning of a revolutionary national
movement, led by a communist leadership, which
succeeded in ousting a colonial government and
establishing an independent, national form of
political system in Vietnam. However more important
is the fact that the Communist ideologies and
strategies of Ho Chi Minh’s hierarchical
communist party, Vietminh, was markedly different
from that of Karl Marx or Lenin, the communist
leaders who had tremendously influenced Ho Chi
Minh. Vietminh was more about the leader Ho, his
ideas and style than about the ideology, the dynamics
of which justifies an analysis of his leadership.
Before analyzing Ho’s leadership, it would
be worthwhile to understand the molding of his
personality character and beliefs, as they were
equally important as his strategies in making
him a successful peoples’ leader. Ho Chi
Minh, named Nguyen Tat Thanh at birth and born
in 1890 in the French occupied Vietnam, was inculcated
with a nationalist spirit and educated in a French
school by his anti-French father, with a view
that it would prepare him in his future struggle
with the French. Ho settled in Paris in 1917,
after his studies and a brief stint of employment,
where he extensively learned the Marxist ideologies
and formed the French Communist Party in 1920.
Ho visited the Soviet Union (Union of Soviet Socialist
Republic) in 1924, where he intensely felt that
it was the duty of all communists to return to
their own country to: “make contact with
the masses to awaken, organize, unite and train
them, and lead them to fight for freedom and independence.”
[Author Unknown, 2004] However, contemplating
the chances of his arrest by French authorities
he settled in the Chinese border of Vietnam in
late 1924 and started organizing the exiled nationalists
into the ‘Vietnam Revolutionary League’.
While the Russian Revolution greatly influenced
Ho, he well recognized that the strategies of
his contemporary Communist leaders in Russia,
Lenin and Stalin, may not be directly applied
to Vietnam, as the Vietnamese working class were
not organized in Vietnam as in Russia and the
peasants were not exposed to exploitation and/or
the class struggle [Warby, 1972] This insight
led him to base his communist ideologies on nationalism
– on the simple and persuasive concepts
of freedom, right to self-determination and equality
. Trained in the western arts of public speaking
and debate, he openly and boldly challenged the
colonial authority, which greatly attracted both
the peasant and aristocracy in Indochina and France
as his movement gained widespread support.
In 1930 Ho Chi Minh assumed leadership of the
newly formed Vietnamese Communist Party of Indochina;
his powerful anti-colonial discourse receiving
widespread reputation and producing immense enthusiasm
that only a mass leader is capable of. While French
colonial government of Indochina sentenced Ho
Chi Minh to death, in absentia, following his
emergence as a Vietnamese icon, Ho was actively
seeking ways to sustain the reputation and enthusiasm
of the Vietnamese populace and gearing it towards
achieving his declared objective – the independence
of Vietnam and the establishment of the Democratic
Republic of Vietnam.
Ho understood that for the Vietnamese, character
and moral standing of the leader had equal, if
not greater, persuasive influence than speech.
[Van, 1964] Working closely with the Vietnamese
peasantry and youth, Ho Chi Minh realized that
sustaining the respect and support of the Vietnamese
society, meant adopting the values and virtues
of the society, by the leadership. The Vietnamese
deeply valued the virtue of conduct – a
conduct equivalent to the quan tu or the ‘superior
man.’ Honesty, sincerity, kindness and simple
way of life are virtues associated with the conduct
of the ‘superior man,’ which were
effectively used by Ho to match his rhetoric.
Ho chose to live as a peasant himself, wearing
a Canadian windcheater and a pair of sandals made
from a discarded tire. His way of life was as
assurance that he had devoted his life to the
service of the people. [Van, 1964] Ever since
Ho settled in Indochina, he essentially remained
a Vietnamese, a peasant, “a man like one’s
ancestors, pure, uncorrupted in a corrupting world,
a man of the land and its simplest virtues.”
[Halberstam,1986; pg. 15 ] The Vietnamese considered
him as “an intransigent and incorruptible
revolutionary” as Saint-Just. [Van 1964,
pg : 33 ] Though many revolutionary leaders emerged
during the period, none of them could impact the
Vietnamese youth and peasantry as Ho Chi Minh;
who with his bold and critical rhetoric and simple
outlook succeeded in impacting Vietnamese, particularly
the younger generations, so much that they were
ready to give “all their strength, all their
devotion to the nation, and if needed, their blood.”
[Halberstam,1986; pg. 60] His reputation for honesty
and sincerity, helped him gain the respect and
confidence of the Vietnamese nation, and contributed
greatly to his success.
Ho’s Assumption of Power
Ho Chi Minh’s political role emerged as
the French surrendered to the Japanese army in
September, 1940 presenting Ho and his fellow nationalists
with the opportunity of freeing their country
from foreign domination, as a new organization
of communist nationalists, Vietminh, was formed.
[Lacouture, 1968] Under the military leadership
of General Vo Nguyen Giap, the Vietminh began
a guerrilla campaign against the Japanese, receiving
weapons and ammunition from the Soviet Union,
and also from the United States after the bombing
of Pearl Harbour by Japan. Immediately after Japan’s
surrender to the Allies on August 14, 1945, Vietminh
forces entered Hanoi and took control of Vietnam
by firing a few symbolic revolver shots. On September
2, 1945 Ho Chi Minh announced the formation of
the Democratic Republic of Vietnam, proclaiming
himself as president of the Provisional Government.
Ho Chi Minh, proclamation took place after the
abdication of Emperor Bao Dai, which he considered
as important event to the common man, as it gave
a ‘heavenly’ mandate to the Vietminh’s
agenda of driving the French out of Vietnam. This
mandate from ‘heaven’ helped Ho and
Vietminh in gaining the loyalty of the Vietnamese
people.[ Dalloz, 1987, pg :50 ]
However, unknown to the Vietminh, as a part of
the ceasefire, Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin
had already decided at a summit-meeting at Potsdam
that post-war Vietnam would be divided into two,
with the northern region under the Chinese rule
and the southern region under the British rule.
This marked the beginning of a new struggle in
Vietminh’s struggle for a united and independent
democratic Vietnam. To add to the complexity,
France tried to reinstate governmental control
over Vietnam after the Second World War, as both
Britain and China agreed to leave Vietnam in January
1946. Internal war broke out between the Vietminh
as the French government refused to recognize
the Democratic Republic of Vietnam as envisioned
by Ho Chi Minh. Though the Vietminh, under General
Giap, had great difficulty in fighting the militarily
advanced French forces, the defeat of Chaing Kai-Shek
in China, by the communist army headed by Mao
Zedong, provided the Vietminh with a safe operational
and training base. [Author Unknown, 2004]
The Vietminh took charge of large areas of North
Vietnam, while Bo Dai, the former emperor of Vietnam
was placed as the chief of State by the French
in the South. Though the French government tried
to negotiate with the Vietminh offering assistance
to set-up a national government and promised eventual
independence to Vietnam its independence, Ho Chi
Minh did not trust the word of the French and
continued the war. Meantime the French public
opinion was turning against the war, which prompted
General Navarre, the French commander in Vietnam,
to contrive General Giap into engaging in a large-scale
battle. These plans to capture the Vietminh was
capitulated as General Giap under the strategic
and influential leadership of Ho Chi Minh mobilized
over 70000 soldiers to encircle and capture the
French troops at Dien Bien Phu. The United States
and Britain declined to offer support to France,
as peace negotiations were on to end the war in
Geneva. The Vietminh launched its attack on March
13, 1954, and after a fifty-six day long attack
causing large-scale causalities to the French
army, France surrendered to the Vietminh on May
7, 1954.
After the defeat of the French colonialists,
as a part of bringing about a peaceful solution
to the conflicts in Vietnam, the foreign ministers
of the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain
and France met at Geneva in April 1954 and decided
on the following:
- Vietnam would be divided at the 17th parallel
-- Ho Chi Minh would rule North Vietnam and Ngo
Dinh Diem, a strong opponent of communism, would
rule South Vietnam
- French troops would withdraw from Vietnam
- The Vietminh would withdraw from South Vietnam;
- The Vietnamese could freely choose to live in
the North or the South
- A General Election for the whole of Vietnam
would be held before July 1956, under the supervision
of an international commission.
[Author Unknown, 2004; Duiker, 1983]
While some members of the Vietminh did not agree
to the agreement, primarily due to the fact that
it called for a division of Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh
maintained that it was only a temporary situation
and was convinced that in the promised General
Election of 1956, the Vietnamese were sure to
elect a communist government to rule a re-united
Vietnam. However Ngo Diem did not concede to holding
elections as promised, and the members of the
Vietminh advocated alternative means including
violence to achieve their objectives. In this
regard it is important to note that many researchers
confirm the popularity of the Vietminh and Ho
Chi Minh, and the high chances that Ho Chi Minh
would be elected to power, had election been conducted
as agreed.
Though Ho Chi Minh was initially opposed to the
idea of using terror and violence as a strategy
and held that the opposition forces in South Vietnam
should concentrate on organizing support rather
than carrying out acts of terrorism against Diem’s
government, he was convinced by Le Duan, his trusted
adviser who after a visit to South Vietnam advised
that if only North Vietnam would provide armed
resistance, a united Vietnam is possible as Diem
had been extremely successful in imprisoning the
leaders of the opposition.
Ho Chi Minh finally agreed to supply arms and
aid to the opposition forces, the opposition not
only including communists but also non-communists
groups. Ho Chi Minh, the Vietnamese nationalist
leader, could also inspire and the lead the different
armed groups to join together and form a more
powerful and effective resistance organization,
which was established in December 1960 and known
as the National Front for the Liberation of South
Vietnam, NLF in short. The NLF was constituted
of many political and religious groups, however,
Ho Chi Minh’s influence on the members of
NLF, was so great that it was considered as a
puppet in the hands of communist leadership of
Hanoi. [Author Unknown, 2004]
The strategies and war tactics of the NLF were
essentially that of Mao Zedong’s Guerrilla
Warfare, Ho being greatly influenced by the Chinese
communists. The NLF organized into small guerilla
groups called cells and the members knew little
about each other -- a strategy adopted so that
a guerilla’s capture did little damage to
the organization. The NLF members were given strict
directives by the leading communist leaders, particularly
Ho, to gain the support of the peasants living
in the rural areas.
[ Duiker, 1983]
The Southern army was assisted by the United
States, and in 1964, President Lyndon B. Johnson,
launched Operation Rolling Thunder to destroy
the North Vietnam economy and to stop the communists
from helping the guerrilla fighters in the south.
Bombing was also directed against territory controlled
by the NLF in South Vietnam. Though Ho Chi Minh
died in 1969, the second Indochina war (Vietnam
War) between the North and South Vietnam, which
started in 1954, extended until 1975, and Ho’s
ideals of communist nationalism continued to influence
the members of the NLF in ultimately defeating
the U.S. and capturing South Vietnam in 1975.
Ho’s vision of the united democratic republic
of Vietnam was established on July 2, 1976, and
was called the Socialist Republic of Vietnam,
or simply Vietnam. [ Duiker, 1983]
Conclusion
Ho’s influence in shaping the nationhood
of communist Vietnam, draws greatly from his persuasive
influence on the common man – an influence
made possible by successfully linking communism
with the rhetoric of democracy and also sustaining
the respect of the common Vietnamese by embracing
the character of ‘quan tu’ and gaining
the ‘mandate of heaven,’ thereby featuring
a cultural heritage that could immediately strike
a chord and strongly influence the common man
to carry out the Vietnamese Communist agenda.
[Van, 1964;Halberstam, 1986 ]
Ho Chi Minh had all the qualities necessary in
a leader, and his sternness, resolve, determination
and whole-hearted devotion to the cause of the
Revolution were an inspiration to all who served
under him and to the nation as a whole. [Van,
1964; pg: x] While his powerful discourses and
simple personae made instant yet lasting impact
on the Vietnamese, the strategies and tactics
adopted by his leadership also proved flawless
in fighting against the world’s super powers
including France, Japan and the United States.
Ho Chi Minh, the eternal spiritual leader of the
Vietnamese communist movement, continues to impact
the Vietnamese society in surviving as a single
nation, ever since the establishment of the Socialist
Republic of Vietnam.
|